The Montreal Convention of 1999 governs most international air carrier liability claims, and it brings structural features to mediation that have no real parallel in domestic tort practice. Once a claimant establishes an "accident" causing death or bodily injury under Article 17, the treaty imposes a two-tier liability scheme. For damages up to 151,880 Special Drawing Rights (roughly $205,000 to $210,000 at current rates, following ICAO's 2024 revision), the carrier cannot exclude or limit its liability by showing it was not at fault. Above that threshold there is no cap; instead, the carrier is presumed liable unless it proves the damage was not due to its own negligence or wrongful act, or was solely due to the negligence of a third party. In practice, this means that in a crash case the threshold question at mediation is rarely whether the carrier pays, but how far above the first tier the damages reach and whether the carrier can credibly carry its burden on the excess. In non-crash cases, such as turbulence or onboard incidents, whether an "accident" occurred at all remains a live issue.
Jurisdiction is the first complication a mediator must understand. Article 33 gives claimants a choice of forum among the carrier's domicile, its principal place of business, the place of business through which the contract of carriage was made, and the place of destination. For death and injury claims, it adds a fifth: the passenger's principal and permanent residence, if the carrier operates services to or from that country and conducts business there from premises it or a partner carrier leases or owns. These provisions fix the country; local rules, including forum non conveniens in U.S. courts, still govern where within it the case proceeds. Consider a Brazilian family flying a European carrier to Miami as their final destination: counsel on both sides may be litigating in a jurisdiction none of them practices in regularly, under a treaty that is the exclusive source of the carrier's liability. That exclusivity matters at the mediation table. Article 29 bars punitive and other non-compensatory damages, and claims that fall outside the treaty's conditions — such as emotional distress without bodily injury — cannot be repackaged as state-law torts. A claimant's counsel who has not fully absorbed that reality will anchor demands to numbers the treaty will not support.
Damages under the Convention are compensatory only, and the treaty itself does not define what harms are compensable or who may recover; those questions are left to the applicable domestic law. In wrongful death cases this is where much of the real valuation work happens. A Miami-filed case will apply Florida's choice-of-law rules, which may lead to the Florida Wrongful Death Act or, for foreign domiciliaries, to the law of the decedent's home country, and a crash over the high seas may bring the Death on the High Seas Act into play. The same accident litigated in New York could produce a different distribution among survivors. Getting the right damages expert in the room — or at least getting both sides to agree on the applicable law before the mediation begins — is essential groundwork. Where the SDR threshold or the caps on delay and baggage are in play, the parties should also agree on the exchange rate and valuation date, since the Convention converts at the date of judgment. Counsel should also keep in mind the two-year period in Article 35, which courts treat as a condition precedent rather than a limitations period subject to tolling, so pre-suit mediation must be scheduled with that deadline firmly in view.
The practical dynamics of these mediations are shaped by the fact that the carrier's insurer, not the carrier itself, is usually the real decision maker on the defense side. International aviation insurers are sophisticated, experienced, and know what cases are worth in the jurisdictions where they are filed. That experience can be an asset because it tends to keep negotiations grounded, but it can also create a gap between what the insurer considers a reasonable number and what a grieving family considers acknowledgment of their loss. The mediator's job is to bridge that gap without letting either side lose sight of the legal framework that defines the boundaries of recovery. In my experience, the cases that settle efficiently are the ones where claimants' counsel has done the treaty analysis rigorously, the insurer has authorized a number that reflects the real exposure, and the mediator has created enough space for the human dimensions of the loss to be acknowledged before the numbers are put on the table.
Sources
- Clyde & Co: Montreal Convention Liability Limits, 2024 Revisions
- WeirFoulds: Revised limits take effect December 28, 2024
- ICAO 2024 revision notice (CAAT)
- IMF SDR valuation